October 18, 2017

Analysis Finds More Renewables Are New Mexico’s Cleaner and Cheaper Choice

Scientists Say Utilities’ Push to Expand Natural Gas as Coal Retreats Is Shortsighted

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (October 18, 2017)—While the legislative effort to strengthen New Mexico’s renewable portfolio standard (RPS) did not pass earlier this year, a new analysis by the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) finds significantly increasing the state’s share of electricity from solar and wind would spur job creation, improve public health and benefit the environment.

The analysis concludes that adding more wind and solar power is the state’s cheapest option. Despite this, some of the state’s largest utilities continue to plan for long-term investments in natural gas expansion.

“The looming question for policymakers is, what replaces coal?” said Julie McNamara, lead author of the study and energy analyst at UCS.

New Mexico’s remaining coal plants are facing strong market pressure to retire early due to unfavorable economics.

“Utilities are building renewables, but also are proposing much more natural gas,” she said. “Our analysis shows this would be the wrong choice. Major fossil fuel investments will be neither cheaper nor cleaner.”

In 2016, renewables accounted for 14 percent of New Mexico’s electricity production. This amount is set to increase once several projects under construction or in development are completed.

The current state RPS, enacted in 2004 and strengthened in 2007, set a target of 20 percent renewable generation by 2020 for investor-owned utilities. Standards like this are a proven, market-based policy tool requiring utilities to meet a growing share of their retail sales through renewable resources. The state electric utilities are on target to easily meet the current 2020 goal.

Earlier this year, the New Mexico Legislature proposed strengthening the requirement to 50 percent by 2030 and 80 percent by 2040. While the bill did not pass, legislative leaders expect to consider similar proposals during upcoming sessions.

The UCS analysis found that with a strengthened RPS, New Mexico would nearly triple its 2016 wind capacity and more than double its 2016 solar capacity by 2030. This increased capacity would result in more than $6 billion in capital investment; nearly 2,400 new jobs in construction, operations, maintenance and other related fields by 2030; $21 million annually in state and local tax revenue; and as much as $9.5 million annually in land-lease payments. Under a strengthened RPS, typical monthly electric bills for households in most years would be lower than they were in 2016.

In addition, the reduction in pollution from closed coal plants can generate health-care savings of about $305 million by 2030, and result in an 85 percent drop in carbon emissions—the principal contributor to global warming.

While the decline of New Mexico’s coal industry is inevitable, what replaces it is not. In addition to building some renewables, the state’s largest electric utilities, including Public Service Company of New Mexico, are also proposing a steadily increasing dependence on another fossil fuel: natural gas. Expansion into natural gas risks ratepayer investment in stranded assets, infrastructure such as pipelines that would be abandoned due to the country’s expected shift away from fossil fuels; price volatility that can affect monthly bills; smaller reductions in carbon emissions; and fewer improvements to public health.

“New Mexico is truly at an energy crossroads,” said Jeff Deyette, report co-author and director of state policy and analysis at UCS. “Because investments in energy infrastructure last decades, what state leaders decide to do next will profoundly affect ratepayers, the economy and New Mexico’s communities for a generation or more.”

New Mexico is rich with renewable energy potential thanks to vast, untapped wind, solar and geothermal resources. These resources have attracted the attention of out-of-state utilities, developers and large corporations looking for ready access to cheap, clean energy. Multiple wind projects under construction or in development are slated to send their power out of state.

“No doubt renewables will play a significant role in the state’s future,” said Deyette. “It’s time for New Mexico’s residents to also enjoy those benefits. Policymakers and residents must decide if they want to intentionally seize the considerable in-state job growth, community investment and public health improvements that come from turning towards a strengthened RPS and away from natural gas.”

The Union of Concerned Scientists puts rigorous, independent science to work to solve our planet's most pressing problems. Joining with people across the country, we combine technical analysis and effective advocacy to create innovative, practical solutions for a healthy, safe, and sustainable future.