Catalyst Summer 2013

[LETTERS]

Do More Wind Turbines Mean Less Wind?

What is the long-term global and local effect of large-scale wind energy harvesting? There must be one: weather is a system, and taking energy out of a system means it will change. Has anyone studied this? There has to be a limit of some kind at some point.

Dan Downing
Reading, PA

 

UCS responds:

It is true that as the number of wind turbines at a given site increases, the speed of the wind moving through the site decreases, which affects those turbines downwind. Wind developers take this “wind drag” or “wake loss” into account (along with other factors) when siting turbines in order to ensure optimal electricity generation.

While more research is needed, a few recent studies estimate that large-scale development of wind power may be limited to around one watt per square meter of land (W/m2) when wind drag is taken into account. Fortunately, we have a long way to go before this level of density is reached: a 2012 study by the National Renewable Electricity Laboratory found that wind power could reliably supply about 40 percent of U.S. electricity use by 2050—up from 3.5 percent in 2012—with a production density of only 0.02 W/m2 averaged across the 48 contiguous states.

Wind production density will be higher in states with greater wind potential, but still not approaching the estimated upper limit. For example, Texas, which already leads the nation in installed wind capacity, has the potential to meet all of its electricity needs with a production density of only 0.08 W/m2.

Some studies have shown that wind turbines can have an effect on local climatic conditions: because turbine blades mix the air, they tend to make surface air temperatures slightly warmer at night and slightly cooler during the day. However, these localized variations have little impact compared with the continuing rise in Earth’s average temperature due to increased global warming pollution from burning fossil fuels. Wind power generates no heat-trapping emissions during operation, thereby lessening the impact our nation’s electricity system has on the global climate.

Steve Clemmer, director of research and analysis,
UCS Climate and Energy Program

 

 

We Want to Know
What is the best thing you have done to reduce your household energy use?

We will publish selected responses (edited for length) in the fall issue of Catalyst.
You can respond via

•           Email: catalyst@ucsusa.org
•           Facebook: www.ucsusa.org/observations